Thanks for reply terpe I've got a solicitor working on the case for me he is not a expert on immigration but has done some cases in the past , I have got all the official papers from the tax office for my earnings I gave them every single receipts of monthly payments made to my wife to me the main thing they seem to be refusing my wifes visa is that they don't believe my earnings would u say that's the case terpe in the way u read the appeal refusal letter cheers again for ur help
