Interesting debate....
I currently have the I Phone 4s, prior to that I had Galaxy S2, I Phone 4 and I Phone 3.
While the Galaxy S2 was a good phone, I prefered the usability of the I Phone.
For me its easy to use without thinking "how do I"
My wife uses I Phone 4 and she pays her own contract
She is still spoiled at times, as I am

but likes to use her own money for things to.....thats why she works too
I guess if your Em gets either the I Phone 4s or Galaxy S3 she will love whatever one get decides to get, as they are both great phones....For me the S3 is too big lol
Cheers
