The thing is Lastlid I have a nice collection of photographs all attached to A4 sheets of paper that they returned to my wife with the original refusal. They have also enclosed copies of my passport on 2 seperate sets of documents, the original set they returned and the set they sent to HMCTS for the appeal. I cannot believe that these people are really this incompetent. I'm phoning Victoria Sharkey's office tomorrow to see if they will help me as she seems to have had some favourable mentions on the forum in the past.